Producer prices can fall while shoppers pay more because the two indexes follow different transactions and cover different items. The US Producer Price Index, or PPI, tracks prices received by domestic producers. The Consumer Price Index, or CPI, measures prices paid by urban consumers. A lower price at the factory can coincide with a higher price at the store, even for the same product.
Follow the product from factory to checkout
Suppose a US manufacturer sells a case of the same product directly to a retailer in each of two consecutive months. There is no change in quality or package size, and assume no sales tax. The retailer buys and sells the case within each month. These are hypothetical prices in US dollars per case, before any seasonal adjustment.
| Measure | Month one | Month two |
|---|---|---|
| Price received by the factory | USD 80 | USD 76 |
| Price paid by the shopper | USD 100 | USD 103 |
| Dollar gap per case | USD 20 | USD 27 |
The price received by the factory falls 5% from the previous month, while the shopper’s price rises 3%. The difference between the two price changes is 8 percentage points. The retailer’s dollar gap widens by USD 7 per case before operating costs. It could reflect changes in the cost of selling the product, the retailer’s pricing decision or both. These prices alone cannot identify the reason or establish what happened to net profit. The two percentage changes are for one product, and illustrate the gap at the transaction level.
Why the two indexes can diverge even without a bigger retail gap
The US Bureau of Labor Statistics PPI guide explains that the PPI covers domestically produced goods and services, including output sold to businesses, governments and foreign buyers. An imported product purchased by a household can enter CPI, while the foreign producer’s selling price is outside US PPI. A US retailer’s margin service on that item can still be covered by a PPI trade series.
Housing illustrates another difference. CPI includes owners’ equivalent rent, an estimate of the rental value of owner occupied housing. That component is outside the scope of PPI for personal consumption. CPI also includes applicable sales and excise taxes in the prices consumers pay. PPI excludes those taxes from the revenue it measures for the producer.
The BLS comparison of personal consumption PPI and CPI identifies personal consumption PPI as a closer comparison than the full final demand PPI. Differences in coverage and measurement still matter. PPI trade services commonly measure the margin earned for distributing a good. The shelf price itself is a different observation. See the Federal Reserve Education comparison for a walkthrough of the two perspectives.
What to compare in an inflation release
- Use the same period and adjustment convention. Compare monthly with monthly and changes over twelve months with changes over twelve months. Compare rates of change, since the two index levels can use different reference periods.
- Check the categories contributing to the move. Compare producer and consumer measures for a closely matched product where possible. Housing, imports and services can move headline CPI even when a familiar producer series is falling.
- Look for additional evidence before attributing a gap to pricing power or predicting pass through. Contracts, the timing of inventory purchases, consumer demand and competition can all affect the speed and size of a price change.
Start with how CPI weights become inflation contributions to identify which prices are doing the work in the consumer index. Use the guide to reading economic releases to verify dates and adjustment conventions.
Sources checked on 21 November 2026. The calculation is hypothetical. The original caricature is a generated illustration. Generative tools assisted preparation.



